Probly Fine officially came together in September 2024 when Amy Reynolds, Lindsay Durden, Susan Milani, and Heather Brookshire decided to join forces. Just a few months later, they stepped on stage for their very first Regional contest in May 2025 and proudly walked away with a 3rd place finish! When all the Regional contests wrapped up, their score earned them a coveted Wildcard spot at the 2025 Sweet Adelines International Quartet Contest in Columbus, OH—an extraordinary achievement for a brand-new quartet in their very first competition season. With a vibrant mix of voices and a shared love for harmony, Probly Fine is excited to keep making music together—and having a lot of fun along the way. 

Lindsay Durden, Lead

Lindsay is a Georgia native, and was raised in Lithonia. For the past 11 years, she has thrived as the office manager at PES Structural Engineers. A passionate performer, Lindsay has been a dedicated member of Song of Atlanta Show Chorus since 2002, combining her love of music, dancing, and harmony. When she’s not working or rehearsing, you’ll find her at home with her partner, Ryan, and their two adored pups, Beau and Eli, making new memories in their recently purchased home in Tucker.

Amy Ryenolds, Tenor

Amy, a proud native Texan, made Georgia her home in the early 90s. She discovered her love for singing in 1995 and has been singing and dancing with Song of Atlanta Show Chorus ever since. Professionally, Amy serves as a Director of Operations at Emory Healthcare. She and her husband, Tim, have four children (Owen, Stephen, Braden, & Megan) and enjoy life together in Cumming.

Susan Milani, Bass

Susan is from Charleston but made Georgia her home in 1995. After attending a Big Chicken show and seeing FRED perform, she was hooked. She chatted with Becki Hine after the show and attended her first SOA rehearsal that week and has been singing with SOA ever since. She has also sung in many quartets over the years winning Regional contest 7 times! Susan has been married to her husband, Bob, for almost 31 years and they have two children, Gabby & Jack. They currently reside in Kennesaw, but are looking forward to retiring to Milledgeville in the next few months.

Heather Brookshire, Baritone

Heather is originally from Alabama and made Georgia her home in 2011. She is a dedicated stay-at-home mom to three beautiful children! Since 2017, she has been an enthusiastic member of Song of Atlanta Show Chorus, where she has proudly participated in six quartets, achieving an impressive five third-place regional finishes. In addition to her passion for music, Heather is an avid cat enthusiast. She shares her home in Woodstock with her husband, Thomas, their children, Julia, Jack, and baby Ginny, and their fur babies.